The Real Crisis: Bill Plotkin’s Map of Human Development and Our Collective Failure to Grow Up
- Sovereign Serpent
- Sep 16
- 7 min read
We are living in a time of collapse. Not only the collapse of ecosystems, governments, and economies, but of psyche, soul, and meaning. We are watching the outward structures of our world fail because inwardly, we have failed to mature. This is the crisis beneath the crisis.
Bill Plotkin, eco-depth psychologist and founder of Animas Valley Institute, gave us one of the clearest maps of human development in his “Nature-Based Map of the Human Psyche” and his stages of the soul’s journey toward wholeness. Unlike conventional developmental psychology—which ends at adulthood as though reaching eighteen is the apex of human growth—Plotkin insists that true adulthood, and certainly true eldership, is a rare and endangered achievement in the modern West.
The uncomfortable truth: most of us never grow up.
And this failure is not only personal—it is systemic. Parents can’t guide children into true adulthood because they themselves were never initiated. Our schools, instead of cultivating wholeness, groom us into obedience and productivity. Our culture rewards adolescence and punishes maturity. We live in a society of “patho-adolescents”—people who have grown older without truly growing up.
This is not an insult. It is an indictment. And it is also an invitation.
Because if this is the root of the crisis we are facing—climate chaos, violence, addiction, consumerism, political polarization—then perhaps the way forward begins not in more technological solutions, but in reclaiming the ancient art of becoming fully human.
The Stages of Soul Initiation
Plotkin’s stages are not linear rungs to climb like a career ladder. They are more like seasons of the psyche. Each stage has its sacred tasks, its gifts, its dangers, and its thresholds. When we complete the task of one stage, we are ripened enough to move into the next. When we don’t, we remain fixated, uninitiated, and stunted—regardless of our chronological age.
Here’s a simplified overview of the stages:
The Innocent in the Nest (Early Childhood) The stage of bonding, belonging, safety. The child must experience being welcomed, nurtured, and held. Without this, everything else is fragile.
The Explorer in the Garden (Middle Childhood) The stage of wonder, curiosity, and play. Here the child learns to explore safely, to imagine, to discover the world.
The Thespian at the Oasis (Early Adolescence) The stage of learning belonging in a human community, discovering social roles, experimenting with masks and identities. Here, approval and peer groups matter.
The Wanderer in the Cocoon (Late Adolescence) The threshold of true soul encounter. The young person must descend into mystery, solitude, and nature to discover who they really are, outside of roles and approval. This is the stage where most modern people are blocked.
The Apprentice at the Well-Spring (Early Adulthood) Having found the soul’s calling, one apprentices themselves to it, offering it to community in growing, imperfect ways.
The Artisan in the Wild Orchard (Late Adulthood) A true adult. One who embodies their unique gift fully in service to both people and planet. They live for something beyond themselves.
The Master in the Grove of Elders (Early Elderhood) A wisdom-holder. Someone who tends culture, guides initiations, and safeguards the soul of the community.
The Sage in the Mountain Cave (Late Elderhood) One who becomes mythic themselves, a keeper of the deepest mysteries, a bridge between worlds.
Now here’s the staggering thing: most of our society never completes Stage 4.
We stop at adolescence. We master the arts of performance, of fitting in, of consumption, of outward achievement—but we never enter the cocoon of the Wanderer. We never endure the soul-initiation that would strip away our false masks and reveal our true essence.
And because of this, our “adults” are still adolescents. Our leaders are still adolescents. Our teachers, our parents, our CEOs, our presidents—all patho-adolescents, still performing for approval, still hoarding resources, still terrified of silence and death.
The True Crisis
We are not only facing climate change, economic collapse, and political violence. We are facing a developmental crisis.
We are a culture of uninitiated beings running institutions, raising children, and wielding technologies that outpace our wisdom. The problem is not only fossil fuels or corporate greed. The problem is immaturity.
Think of it:
Climate change is the result of adolescent consumption unchecked by adult restraint.
Capitalism in its current form is the result of adolescent craving for more, more, more.
Polarization and violence are adolescent responses to difference: “us vs. them.”
Addiction epidemics are adolescent attempts to fill the hole left by the absence of true belonging and soul encounter.
In other words: the crisis we face is not external. It is internal. It is psychological. It is spiritual.
And our institutions—schools, governments, media—are not designed to solve this. In fact, they perpetuate it. The education system, for example, does not guide children into wholeness. It conditions them to become obedient workers, to memorize and regurgitate information, to compete. It stops at Stage 3. Our schools create thespians, not wanderers.
Parents, through no fault of their own, pass down what they received. If they were never initiated, how can they guide their children into initiation? You cannot give what you never received.
This is why we see entire generations adrift, medicated, distracted, enraged. It’s not that people are lazy or selfish. It’s that their deepest developmental needs have gone unmet.
What We Have Lost
In traditional, earth-based cultures, initiation was not optional. Adolescence was marked by ritualized descent into the wild, into solitude, into trial. The community created conditions for the soul to be revealed. The young person was not left to flounder. They were guided by elders, witnessed, and welcomed back as a true adult, with responsibilities and gifts to carry.
We have lost this.
We have ceremonies for graduation, for marriage, for retirement—but not for becoming human. We have rituals of consumerism (the first car, the first drink, the wedding registry), but not rituals of descent and rebirth.
And so we wander in bodies that are adult but psyches that are adolescent.
This is the real crisis.
A Way Forward: Reclaiming Initiation
So what do we do? How do we face this?
The first step is to name it. To stop pretending that maturity comes with age, or that a college degree, a mortgage, or a job title equals adulthood. To stop mistaking performance for depth.
The second step is to reintroduce practices of initiation. This doesn’t mean copying indigenous cultures or appropriating rituals that are not ours. It means recovering the universal human necessity of soul encounter, descent, and rebirth.
This can look like:
Time alone in wild nature, fasting, listening, stripped of distractions.
Shadow work, dream work, and depth psychology practices that confront us with what we’ve exiled.
Mentorship and guidance from those who have gone before us, even if rare.
Building communities of practice that value depth over speed, soul over surface.
The third step is courage. Because initiation is not comfortable. It is not glamorous. It is a death of the false self. And most of us resist it with everything we’ve got. But it is the only way to move from adolescence into true adulthood.
Why This Matters Now
We are at a collective threshold. The old world is cracking. Systems are breaking down. We can respond in one of two ways:
Collapse further into patho-adolescence, clinging to consumption, distraction, and rage.
Or use this moment as initiation itself—a dark night of the species—out of which true adulthood might emerge.
This is why Plotkin’s work matters so deeply. Because it gives us a map. And while a map is not the journey, it is invaluable when wandering in the dark.
Our task is urgent. Not just for ourselves, but for the generations to come. If we fail to grow up, we leave them a wasteland. If we succeed—even imperfectly—we plant the seeds of a culture that remembers what it means to be human.
A Call to Courage
So I ask you—where are you on the journey? Where have you stopped? Where have you resisted the descent?
It is not too late. The soul does not care about your age. You can be sixty and still enter the Wanderer’s cocoon. You can be seventy and apprentice to your calling. You can be thirty and discover that your true adulthood is only just beginning.
The world does not need more thespians. The world needs Wanderers who dare to listen, Apprentices who dare to serve, Artisans who embody their gift, and Elders who guide us home.
This is the revolution. Not more tech, not more consumption, not more empty promises of progress. The revolution is growing up.
Because if we grow up, everything changes. We consume less. We care more. We hold future generations in mind. We live not for applause, but for service. We remember that the Earth is alive, and we belong to her.
This is not easy work. But it is necessary. And it is sacred.
Closing
Bill Plotkin gave us the map. Our ancestors knew the way. The question is whether we will have the courage to walk it.
Because the true crisis is not “out there.” It is in here. In our refusal, or our willingness, to complete the journey of becoming fully human.
And perhaps—if enough of us dare—the collapse we are living through is not the end, but the beginning. A collective initiation. A cocoon for humanity.
The question is: will we emerge as butterflies—or remain forever caterpillars, clinging to a dying leaf?
BIG Love,
Leah
P.S. If this stirred something in you—if you feel the ache of unfinished initiation, the longing for clarity, or the hunger for a deeper purpose—you don’t have to navigate it alone. This is the work I do. Through my coaching sessions, I help you listen for the call of your soul, untangle the patterns that keep you stuck, and begin to shape a life rooted in meaning, belonging, and impact.
If you’re ready to step out of performance and into your true path, I’d love to walk beside you. You can book a session with me here and begin the journey toward the fullness of who you are meant to be.
Comments